Get your automotive data ad-free: become a premium member today!
Illustration: GCBC

Penske Automotive’s EPS Slipped 5 Cents in a Quarter With 7 Cents of Buyout Costs

Loading the Elevenlabs Text to Speech AudioNative Player...

October 29, 2026

TLDR: Penske Automotive Group reported on October 28 that its third-quarter 2026 earnings per share fell to $3.36 from $3.41, in a quarter that carried $0.07 a share of costs for its pending buyout. Its finance and insurance gross profit per retail vehicle fell $64 to $1,731, a third-quarter fall like those Lithia & Driveway and Group 1 Automotive reported.
Q3, three months to Sept 30 2026 2025
Earnings per share, as reported $3.36 $3.41
F&I gross profit per car $1,731 $1,795
F&I gross profit per car, same-store $1,734 $1,817
Used-car gross profit per car $1,946 $2,083
Commercial truck dealerships, pre-tax income $59.6 million $41.5 million

Source: Penske Automotive Group third-quarter 2026 release, October 28, 2026.

Deal costs were bigger than the decline

Penske Automotive Group’s earnings per share fell for a third straight reporting period, after declines in 2025 and the first half of 2026, its third-quarter release shows. The drop was five cents, and the quarter carried seven cents a share of costs for the buyout by Penske Corporation and Mitsui. Added back, a step the release does not take, those costs would put the quarter at about $3.43 by GCBC’s arithmetic, a little above a year earlier.

The weakness is in the car stores, where the business office made $64 less per car. That office earns a fee on each loan it arranges and a margin on the service contracts and protection plans it sells. Lithia & Driveway reported an $85 fall in the same measure a week earlier, and Group 1 Automotive a $74 fall in its October 28 release.

Less on each car, more from trucks

Retail deliveries of new and used cars rose about half a percent from a year earlier, yet total F&I gross profit fell 2.7%, so the fall is in what each deal earned rather than in how many deals there were. Profit on the vehicles fell too, more on used cars than new, and new-car gross profit per unit was $258 lower than in the second quarter. The release gives no reason, and there was no earnings call to ask.

Truck businesses held Penske’s pre-tax income close to level. Pre-tax income at the commercial truck dealerships rose about 44%, and the company’s earnings from affiliates, nearly all of them from its 28.9% stake in Penske Transportation Solutions, the truck-leasing company, rose 17%. Service and parts gross profit in the car stores rose 2.6%.

Two other ways to read the quarter

The year-earlier $3.41 also includes Penske Motor Group’s results from before Penske Automotive owned it. Accounting rules require that restatement when a business is bought from a company under the same control. The release’s own reconciliation, which counts the group only from November 1, 2025, puts the year-earlier quarter at $3.23. On reported figures, earnings per share fell; on either the deal-cost or the ownership reading, they rose.

This was the first quarter reported since the agreement to take Penske private at $212 a share. The merger agreement also limits buybacks, and the release says the company does not expect to buy back more stock while the deal is pending, so a shrinking share count, down 0.5% this quarter, will not prop up earnings per share the way it did at Lithia.

What to watch

AutoNation reports on October 30, according to its call announcement. Its F&I profit per car is the fourth read on the business office. A fall there would mean four large groups earning less on each finance and protection sale, which looks like the car buyer changing; a flat or higher figure would keep it a problem for three groups. Its service business is the second number: in the first quarter, aftersales carried AutoNation’s results while retail slowed.