2016 Honda Accord Touring Review - GCBC's Favourite Midsize Car

2016 Honda Accord Touring front
The last time we tested a Honda Accord was in January 2014.

That car, an Accord Hybrid, isn't part of Honda's lineup for the 2016 model year, a year that's hosting a round of updates to other Accords.

THE GOOD
• Classy exterior

• Great ride/handling balance
• Typically smooth Honda four-cylinder
• Super stiff structure
• Apple CarPlay!
THE BAD
• Not the biggest rear seat in midsize class
• 19" wheels make ride too firm for some
• Interior could be more intuitive
• Increasingly unappealing sedan format
• Irritating moments with CVT

Midsize cars aren't the force they were just a few short years ago in Canada, and the market's turn away from these intermediate sedans is particularly apparent in Hondaland. The Accord produced 15% of Honda's Canadian sales as recently as 2008; the CR-V compact crossover just 13%. But those numbers have undergone dramatic change since the recession. The Accord is responsible for less than one-in-ten Honda sales in Canada; the CR-V accounts for a quarter of the brand's volume.

Nevertheless, there are still 9000 Canadians who buy or lease a midsize car each month. 

Which one should they choose? We have a recommendation.

WHAT IS IT?
Launched in 1976 as a curious three-door, Japanese upsized compact hatchback, the Accord has managed to stand the test of time with significant updates every four or five years and mid-generational refreshes. For model year 2016, the ninth-generation Accord which debuted for model year 2013 is slightly restyled inside and out, structurally stiffened, and safer. Also, the Accord is now available with Apple CarPlay and Android Auto.
2016 Honda Accord Touring side
2016 HONDA ACCORD TOURING
Base Price: $25,945 *
As-Tested Price: $34,785 *
Drive Type: front-wheel-drive
Transmission: continuously variable
Engine: 2.4L DOHC 16-valve I-4
Horsepower: 185 @ 6400 rpm
Torque: 181 lb-ft @ 3900 rpm
Curb Weight: 3435 pounds
Length: 193.2 inches
Width: 72.8 inches
Height: 57.7 inches
Wheelbase: 109.3 inches
Tires: Continental ContiProContact
Tire Size: 235/40R19
Passenger Volume: 2854 litres
Cargo Volume: 439 litres
EPA City: 28 MPG
EPA Highway: 37 MPG
NRCAN OEE City: 8.6 L/100km
NRCAN OEE Hwy: 6.4 L/100km
Observed: 27.4 mpg
Observed: 8.6 L/100km
* Canadian dollars, includes $1795 in fees.
Pricing for Accord sedans in Canada starts at $25,945, or $27,245 with the optional continuously variable automatic transmission. That $1300 CVT can also be tacked on to the base price of the $28,485 Accord Sport four-cylinder and this $32,885 Accord Touring four-cylinder. 

To get a V6 in the Accord, you must now skip past the LX and Sport trims and head straight for the EX-L and Touring. The V6 adds $3280 to the cost of a four-cylinder EX-L or $2800 to the cost of this Accord Touring CVT. 

If you want to pair the V6 to a 6-speed manual, however, you need to sacrifice a couple of doors. The Accord Coupe Touring V6 6MT costs $37,625, $4740 more than the Accord Coupe Touring I-4 6MT.

HOW BIG IS IT?
The Accord's available passenger volume, while substantial and sufficient, doesn't measure up to the 2016 models of the Hyundai Sonata, Kia Optima, Subaru Legacy, Ford Fusion, Toyota Camry, Volkswagen Passat, Nissan Altima, and Chrysler 200. Similarly, the Accord's cargo volume places the Honda seventh in its class behind the Sonata, 200, Fusion, Optima, Passat, and Chevrolet's new Malibu. 

Yet at 193.2 inches long and 72.8 inches wide, the Accord is 2.3 inches longer than the more spacious Toyota Camry and an inch wider. The Accord is by no means a loser when it comes to the efficiency of its space usage, but other automakers have produced slightly more with slightly less.

Relative to Honda's growing, tenth-generation Civic, the Accord is 10 inches longer, two inches wider, and two inches taller. This creates an Accord cabin that's 6% larger, but the Accord's trunk is less than 3% bigger than the Civic's. 

In addition to size and space and available power, much of what historically separated bigger cars from their compact brethren was refinement, the aura of expense, the impression of solidity. Is that still true with the 2016 Civic, a car which isn't that much smaller than this Accord? We'll find out when we spend a week with the new version of Canada's best-selling car in late January.
2016 Honda Accord Touring rear
DOES IT WORK?
The Accord's interior is not without its letdowns. There's no volume or tuning knob, as Honda's stylish but unnecessarily flush touchscreen makes an unwanted appearance here. The heated seat buttons near the shifter are clunky and only offer two settings. Excessive piano black finishes quickly appear tarnished. And with a modest centre hump, the Accord's rear seat doesn't have the vast large car feel of so many so-called midsize cars.

Yet criticisms against Honda's built-in infotainment unit are now all but moot, with Apple CarPlay and Android Auto now standard across the board. We're among the iPhone faithful here at GCBC, so we didn't test Android Auto. But this, our first experience with Apple CarPlay, was a revelation. Apple didn't do anything spectacular with this system, but everything in Apple CarPlay operates the way you'd expect it to, rather than in the convoluted, nonsensical fashion of so many automotive infotainment units. The music app is better than iTunes on your iPhone or iMac. Messaging, completed through Siri, is safe and simple. And your occupants will love when someone texts you a message full of emojis.


Historical Monthly & Yearly Honda Accord Sales Figures
2014 Honda Accord Hybrid Driven Review
2016 Hyundai Sonata Hybrid Driven Review
2016 Honda Pilot vs. 2015 Honda Odyssey - GCBC Comparison Test


Underway, with my iPhone plugged in, the Accord's seats aren't quite as bolstered as I'd like in a car that can tackle a corner as capably as an Accord Touring on 19-inch wheels with relatively low profile tires. Unless you're accelerating with some haste, the continuously variable transmission is mostly inoffensive, but it will cramp your enthusiastic style.

Only if you do actually possess an enthusiastic style, that is. Accord buyers who don't truly enjoy driving probably won't want this Accord. A less sporting Accord, without this car's more lively, quicker steering and low profile tires will be more suited to a ho-hum daily commute. An Accord on 17-inch wheels won't ride this firmly, nor will it turn in this sharply.
2016 Honda Accord Touring interior
All Photo Credits: Timothy Cain ©www.GoodCarBadCar.net
Click Any Image For A Larger View

Photo Location: Fisherman's Cove, Eastern Passage, Nova Scotia
But oh, for the common Mr. Smith who enjoys driving; who wants to take the long way home in his Mr. Everyday sedan; who wouldn't spend extra on the CVT if he could convince his 17-year-old daughter to learn how to drive a manual; who understands that the expensive 3.5L V6 is unnecessary because this Mr. Commonplace 2.4L I-4 revs so sweetly; the Mr. Nineties who remembers Hondas with double wishbones out back and in front; for that guy, this Accord is the one to have. 

Sweetly balanced, poised and polished, fun but never raucous, the 2016 Honda Accord is a luxury sports sedan without the outlandish power or luxury price tag. It's a quiet and composed sedan that only ever lets its hair down when asked, always hinting at an underlying foundation of traditional Honda dynamics but never displaying the expected accompaniment of excessive wind whistling, road noise, and ugly wheels.

IS ANYONE BUYING IT?
In the United States, the Accord isn't just America's second-best-selling midsize car, it's the second-best-selling car overall. Only the Toyota Camry sells more often. Accord volume in the U.S. is down 10% in 2015, however, even though year-over-year volume increased in each of the last three months. Segment-wide, midsize car volume has fallen 2% in the U.S. through 2015's first 11 months.

In Canada, meanwhile, where midsize car volume is down 7% this year, Accord volume has tumbled 16%. Only the Optima, Altima, and Passat are tumbling faster. November Accord sales spiked to 22% to a segment-leading 1306 units. Honda Canada sells 4.5 Civics for every Accord that leaves the showroom.
2016 Honda Accord Touring Fishermans Cove
SHOULD I BUY SOMETHING ELSE INSTEAD?
No.

Well, maybe. 

The tradition continues in Korea, with the Hyundai Sonata and Kia Optima offering more equipment for the dollar. If the Volkswagen Passat once again becomes available with a diesel engine, the fuel economy benefits of that car make it an interesting choice. The Mazda 6 is a true driver's choice, but it might not be big enough inside for your needs. The Ford Fusion is an enjoyable drive and offers available all-wheel-drive. The Subaru Legacy is bland but provides standard all-wheel-drive. The Toyota Camry, particularly in the XSE V6 format we tested last winter, is priced like this Accord and, surprisingly, is unlikely to disappoint the semi-enthusiast driver. 2016 also sees the debut of an all-new Chevrolet Malibu, a handsome, lightweight car that's earning early plaudits.

HOW MUCH SHOULD I PAY?
If all you need is an Accord that drives like this Accord, the 2016 Honda Accord Sport costs CAD $29,785, or $1300 less if you stick with the 6-speed manual transmission. The Accord Sport features the Touring's big wheels and quicker steering but loses some of the interior's less vital bits. 

In between the Accord Sport and Accord Touring you'll find the Accord Sport with Honda Sensing safety kit: CMBS, FCW, LDW, RDM, ACC, LKAS. (Look'em up.) That car, which comes standard with the continuously variable transmission, adds $1000 to the cost of the non-Honda Sensing Accord Sport with the CVT.

WHAT'S THE VERDICT?
The Honda Accord is the best midsize car on the market today. But that's not to say other midsize cars don't do certain things better than the Accord, nor does it mean that some of the Accord's faults aren't glaring. Indeed, the factors which cause GCBC to declare that the Accord is the best midsize car on the market may not be important to you. You may place greater value on the Camry's legendary reliability, the Mazda 6's curvaceous exterior, the Subaru Legacy's all-wheel-drive, or the Hyundai Sonata's value equation.

But while some competitors are somewhat superior in some areas, the Accord is among the class leaders in every area. At less than $35,000, the 2016 Honda Accord Touring also makes a case for itself as a veritable competitor of $40,000 German sports sedans. The same simply can't be said of the Accord's direct rivals.

Timothy Cain is the founder of GoodCarBadCar.net, which obsesses over the free and frequent publication of U.S. and Canadian auto sales figures. Follow on Twitter @goodcarbadcar and on Facebook. The Accord was supplied by Honda Canada's press office.

No comments:

Post a Comment

Please stay on topic. Feel free to argue and debate, but stay friendly and do not get personal. Comments signed as Anonymous will likely be rejected as possible spam. Login with a Google account or assign yourself a name. Keep in mind, kids read this site.

If the post on which you are commenting is more than 40 days old, the comment will undergo moderation as a means of avoiding spam.