New GoodCarBadCar Feature - Select the make and model in the dropdown on your right to find more than 60 monthly and yearly sales figures for every model on currently on sale. May 2012 U.S. updates are complete as are most Canadian figures. The May U.S. Auto Sales By Brand post and Canadian Auto Sales By Brand post are both complete.

2/16/2010

LBS/BHP - SMART FORTWO AND OTHER SMALL CARS

In the absence of additional vehicle specifications, horsepower figures are irrelevant. Most necessary among the bunch is curb weight, known Across The Pond as kerb weight. The coefficient of drag (CoD) is useful, for sure. Not to mention the final drive ratio. If you're going to rely on bhp or lb-ft to be measuring sticks for your perception of modern cars, those sticks need to account for more information.

Yesterday, for whatever reason, @mr2pitch on Twitter made a comment regarding the smart fortwo's power-to-weight ratio being similar to that of the Hyundai Accent, Toyota Prius, and Honda Insight. Since GoodCarBadCar.net runs an '09 smart fortwo as a long-termer, it got me thinking. In urban situations, our '09 smart fortwo pure always has more than enough power to scoot past more powerful vehicles. More importantly, maintaining illegal highway speeds is a breeze. Yet, I haven't driven many slower vehicles. So is the power-to-weight ratio of the smart fortwo really in the same ballpark as the Accent, Prius, and Insight?

Most certainly. Chasing down flyballs might not be the smart's forte, but stealing bases against unsuspecting pitchers would be about as easy in the other cars mentioned. For a full rundown, The Good Car Guy has calculated the pounds-per-horsepower statistics for a whole bunch of low-powered cars and offered a little bit of context by way of the diesel-engined Volkswagen Jetta TDI, the not-for-North-America turbocharged Brabus smart, an old Ford Excursion V8, and the V8-engined BMW M3, too.

-----

FORD EXCURSION - 27.8 pounds per horsepower
SMART FORTWO - 25.8 pounds per horsepower
HONDA INSIGHT - 24.6 pounds per horsepower
CHEVROLET AVEO - 23.8 pounds per horsepower
TOYOTA PRIUS - 22.7 pounds per horsepower
VOLKSWAGEN JETTA TDI - 22.7 pounds per horsepower
HYUNDAI ACCENT - 22.5 pounds per horsepower
TOYOTA YARIS - 22.3 pounds per horsepower
HONDA FIT - 21.3 pounds per horsepower
SMART FORTWO BRABUS - 18.2 pounds per horsepower
BMW M3 - 8.9 pounds per horsepower

Keep in mind, trim levels and options can throw the curb weights into question, so run with the examples The Good Car Guy has chosen.

1 Comments:

  1. yetisoulxbcube2/16/2010 1:54 PM

    Give me a turbocharged smart then

    ReplyDelete

Please stay on topic. Feel free to argue and debate, but stay friendly and don't get personal. Comments signed as Anonymous may be rejected. Keep in mind, kids read this site.

If the post on which you are commenting is more than 40 days old, the comment will need to be moderated as a way to avoid spam.